.
Saturday, May 8, 2010

Sarkozy Will Get “Stuffed”

It appears that the markets are in for some action next week. The EU leaders have pledged to put a package of measures on the table for the market to absorb by Sunday evening.

There are no details of what may be coming as of yet. This is happening so fast that I doubt they actually have a plan. What plans they will come up with are all going to be short term fixes for the excessive volatility we have seen.

We know from an article by Jon Hilsenrath at the WSJ that the US Fed has opened existing swap lines to the ECB. This means that intervention in the currency markets is coming. I wrote about this last week. My thinking is the same today. If the ECB has a “Go it alone” plan to intervene in the FX markets it will not work for long. Only coordinated intervention including BOE and the US Fed will have anything but a short-term impact. Therefore it is critical to see who is going to be involved come Monday.

There are a number of news leaks that suggest that a Euro 600 billion emergency lending facility will be put in place to support Europe’s 1,000 banks that are in need of some “Fast Cash”. This is terrible news. This just confirms that those same banks were facing a liquidity crisis at week’s end (AKA- A run on the bank). While E600b is a big amount of money it is a drop in the bucket when it comes to the total funding requirements in Europe. The question will quickly arise, “What happens when the 600B is gone?” This is quite different from the TARP approach where equity was thrown at the banks. That equity had a 10-15X’s leverage affect. This is just a new funding source. It does nothing to address the quality of the assets being funded.

What is missing from the leaks from the EU is a plan to buy distressed sovereign debt in the public market to absorb the excess supply and beef up prices. We know there is pressure from the Banks to have this happen. They are sitting on underwater sovereign bonds. These are public securities with a massive float. I don’t think  the ECB has the resources to make much of a dent in the bond market. It is much bigger than they are. If they drive the prices of sovereign debt higher it is likely that they will get offers for more than they could possibly buy. There may be some demand from global investors for Spanish debt at 6%; there will be no private demand if the rate is artificially set at 4%. The higher they drive up bonds the more sellers they will meet.

On the issue of buybacks one has to ask, “Where will they get the money?” A credible buyback would have to start at Euro 500b. Is Germany going to backstop that? I can’t believe that they will. If they do, their debt cost will just rise and nothing will have been accomplished. My worst fear is that in order to finance the buy ins they look to the Federal Reserve Bank in NY to provide dollar based funding.

I don’t think that America has yet woken up to the fact that our share of the Greek bailout is ~$20b (via the IMF quota). When we learn that the Fed is funding Europe with big money there will be a backlash. The Fed is already in hot water for their easy money policy. A $500b loan to Europe by the Fed will not go over too well with the folks in America. If something like this were agreed to over the weekend and we wake up on Monday with a new bailout there will be a very sharp reaction. Several folks in D.C. (Grayson) will attempt to stop it. Bernanke understands this, Geithner does as well (maybe). A new Marshall Plan for Europe is simply not in the cards. If that is what is attempted it will fail miserably. The most likely outcome will be that the US is rapidly sucked into the European sovereign debt crisis.

There is some very clear anger being voiced from the leaders in Europe. French President Sarkozy stuck his foot deeply in his (mouth) on Friday night with these words:

“We will confront speculators mercilessly. They will know once and for all what lies in store for them.”

In my view this was a stupid move. He is saying, “Come on speculators, I will take you all on and crush you!” He has not one chance in a 1,000 to achieve that. His words prove that he has no idea what he is talking about. This not a matter of evil speculators and their evil tools (CDS). This is about massive fiscal imbalances that everyone understands are unsustainable. Borrowing more to fix the problem will be the end game for Europe.

It is likely that as a result of what will be forthcoming there will be some very big swings in market prices on Monday. The Vol. will be going up, not down. The initial result will, no doubt, be a backup in many markets. The Euro will be higher, European sovereign bonds will trade higher; maybe even equities could catch a bid. But the critical question will be, “For how long?” Depending on the resolve of those in charge this could last for a bit. At least a week and more likely a month. But it is doomed to failure. Should we get to June and the benefits of these emergency steps wane there will be yet another crisis. The bonds will fall again as will the Euro. When that happens there will be no second bailout. Sometime in the next two months we will hear that great sucking noise again. And when it is heard there will be no stopping it.

Get your seat belt on speculators. You are about to be attacked. This will be a lifetime opportunity to make money. For investors, stay clear of this. There is nothing but risk and downside. “Risk off” is the right place to be if you don’t have a helmet on. I can’t wait.

Comments

  1. Mr. Kowalski says:
  2. Jeepers, I haven’t finished typing yet Mr. K.

  3. "DoctoRx" says:

    In your scenario, do you see real buying continuing to come into the Treasury market, that is until “they” shoot us too?

  4. Anonymous says:

    Where have I heard this idea of buying up “undervalued” assets before? Outstanding. As you point out, there should be exciting viewing from a safe distance.

  5. Dr. RX. Over the past few weeks Treasury yields have fallen to six month lows. So the US has been the safe have place to go. Should there be a big effort to shore up Europe it follows that capital will flow back out of the safe haven. I would expect US bond prices to be lower on Monday. We shall see.

  6. Bruce,

    Agreed with what you wrote. I had a close look at January and then March Greek plan: no way it could work; their assumptions were taken from fantasy land. I have modified my model with last WE agreement: it does not work either; EUR 120 billion more debt en 2013 than in 2009, 170% debt/GDP and 14% deficit/GDP (http://marketsandbeyond.blogspot.com/2010/05/greece-final-chapter-at-last.html).

    Sarkozy (lime most politicans) is looking for scapegoats ans is scared to death because of French banks exposure to Greece and Spain (not so much to Portugal where Spanish bank are the winners…)and the very bad fiscal situation of France. The current PM, Mr. Fillion, said two years ago that France was broke (and was reprimanded by Sarkozy). They are in panic mode, and in panic mode, particularly when one is arrogant, one says stupid things like the quote you highlighted.

    Regarding the new plan, fine,, it will have some effect short term, but fundamental are there to stay and the fall will only be more painful.

  7. Namazu says:

    Will “this sucker could go down” wind up being the most insightful and pragmatic reaction by a head of state to this long financial nightmare?

  8. Anonymous says:

    I just dont get it ..why these countries keep borrowing on top of borrowing is beyond me…it make absolutely no sence what so ever
    Why cant they acknowledge the fact that countries have over dont it on the global credit card
    can someone enlighten me on this global debt ???

  9. Mr. Kowalski says:

    “why these countries keep borrowing on top of borrowing is beyond me”

    Quite simple,really.. politicians are primarily concerned with their legacy; how history views them. They’re scared to death of being thought of as the next Herbert Hoover. So.. it’s easier to quietly kick the can down the road and have the problem blow up in the next guy’s face. An example is how Obama did health care.. the benefits (and the lions share of costs) don’t start until after he’s gone. Sadly for him, the economic problems of the past are going to catch up to him, perhaps even before he has a chance to pass any sort of financial reform. His words “never again should the American people have to pay for failed banks” will come back to haunt him, perhaps even this week.

  10. Anonymous says:

    Whats your take on the week ahead for the markets ?

  11. Anonymous says:

    Bruce,
    I enjoy your insights, but I think you make a critical error when you suggest the ECB does not have the resources. They are a CB with infinite resources and can buy as much Greek or Spainish debt as they want. The questions with QE is whether it generates inflation and devalues the currency and, if not (witness Japan), what happens when it ends. The real issue is at what point the German voter says “Enough”.

    Dean Jackson

  12. Dean, No they can’t. If we wake up Monday with the ECB bidding 4% for PIIG bonds the are going to get a few trillion on offer. So what are they going to do? Offer to buy Greek ten year at 8%??

    That accomplishes absolutely nothing. Greece does not work unless it trades at Germany +100. They are going to buy bonds up to the point where the countries debt service falls to a manageable number? For all the PIIGS? Where does that money come from? They print it? That is not going to happen in the EU any more than it would happen in the US. There is no stomach for that anymore.

    The ECB is not that big.

  13. Anonymous says:

    What is your take on FX speculation from the viewpoint of the Swedish Krona in the current situation? Long on USD, short on EUR, or?

  14. Anonymous says:

    Bruce,
    With all due respect, we will agree to disagree. Helicopter Ben did just that in the US, bought well in excess of a Trillion various government securities and, once faced with the Fed’s unlimited capacity to increase reserves, not too many seemed to be shorting against it. Don’t get me wrong, I am not saying it works longer term, just that is a potential line of defense the Europeans may adopt. And it could be effective longer than one might suspect if the US and other CBs support their efforts in a concerted action like the Plaza and Lourve Accords of an earlier era.
    DJ

  15. DJ I tried to make the point that you do. If what is to come is a program equivalent to the Plaza/Louvre accords it is significant. But I do not see that happening. Japan will not be involved neither will BOE. The question is what is the Feds role going to be?

    We will see in a few hours how big a deal this is. If it is not “shock and awe” as Sarkozy suggests it is going to be big day in the markets.

  16. eh says:

    Over the past few weeks Treasury yields have fallen to six month lows.

    This is exactly what they want because the federal government has a LOT of debt to sell. Personally I don’t exclude the possibility this whole ‘crisis’ is being stage managed for just that reason.

  17. Mr. Kowalski says:

    “If it is not “shock and awe” as Sarkozy suggests it is going to be big day in the markets”

    I completely agree.. if all we get is hot air and a flimsy bandaid, tomorrow will make Black Tuesday look like amateur hour.

  18. Anonymous says:

    is it possible this could all be theatre for the manipulative value ?? people are dying in greece ??

  19. Mr. Kowalski says:

    Some news from Germany: First, Angela Merkel’s coalition has lost the off-election in Westphalia. Second, the German Finance Minister Schaubel has apparently been taken to the hospital; an adverse reaction to medication. Lets hope the medication of which we speak was’nt the bailout.

  20. Anonymous says:

    I had a funny feeling A Merkel’s coalition would loose the way the polls have been coming out from Germany…Is a possiblity the coalition may not have enough power to proceed with the loan to Greece ? and more importantly what effect will this have on the markets ?

  21. Anonymous says:

    “A $500b loan to Europe by the Fed will not go over too well with the folks in America. If…we wake up on Monday with a new bailout there will be a very sharp reaction.”

    There will be political eruptions in 50 states and state capitals that will rearrange American politics. There is no politically salable explanation for why Portugal, Ireland, Italy, Greece and Spain get Federal Reserve backed bailouts and, say, California doesn’t.

  22. Anon; Not to worry. As part of the deal the ECB has agreed to bail out Cali…..

  23. Anonymous says:

    “bail out Cali…”

    Ok. And what about Florida? I’d like to use that air hose over here for a few minutes…

    The first part of your scenario has played out perfectly. The markets are panicking upwards nicely. FTSE 100, DAC and CAC all have short squeezes from hell underway. Probably Fx markets too.

    Still expecting early June for the markets to generally recognize the new Euro Emperor has no clothes?

  24. Anonymous says:

    Mr K
    This bailout is good ? whats your take on the coming days and weeks ahead for the EU and USA ?

Trackbacks

  1. [...] of an article I wrote more than two years ago titled, Sarkozy Will Get “Stuffed” (link). The occasion was a stupid remark made by then French President Nicholas Sarkozy regarding some new [...]

  2. [...] of an article I wrote more than two years ago titled, Sarkozy Will Get “Stuffed” (link). The occasion was a stupid remark made by then French President Nicholas Sarkozy regarding some new [...]

  3. [...] reminded of an article I wrote more than two years ago titled, Sarkozy Will Get “Stuffed” (link). The occasion was a stupid remark made by then French President Nicholas Sarkozy regarding some new [...]