Friday, November 9, 2012

CBO on “Ultimate Can Kicking”


The Congressional Budget Office is out with a very well timed report on what the hell should be done with debt, deficits, taxes and the economy.



There is a lot of information in the reports. (link), (link)  I doubt that too many of the folks in Congress will bother to read it. I looked through it; I think the following chart is the one the deciders in D.C. will focus on:





Lots of policy options are measured in the chart. Think like a politician, and go to the bottom line. What set of proposals has the biggest bang?  My summary from the CBO chart:


-Totally junk the scheduled spending cuts for the military.


-Do away with all of the mandatory non-defense cuts (sequestration).


-Don’t do anything with taxes. Roll over everything for a couple of more years.


-Extend the 2% payroll tax break for two years.


If we kick the can down the road for a few more years, what do we get? The deep thinkers have come up with numbers that look pretty attractive. The CBO thinks that significant benefits could be realized as soon as September 30, 2013.


In terms of jobs, the CBO reckons that as many as 3.4m jobs could be created/saved if everything on the cliff is pushed off to the future.


The economy would be much stronger if the can is kicked. The difference between falling off the cliff and extending everything is 2.9% of GDP. That’s a very big number; it comes to $500Bn of top-line growth.


Well, that sounds good. What would this cost? The CBO puts the tab at an incremental $503Bn in 2013 and another dollop of red ink in 2014 of $682Bn. (The base line debt is ~$850Bn for 2012/13. The can-kick would be on top of the base line numbers)



Who would go for a plan like this? Very Important People like Paul Krugman and Larry Summers, would probably say that the stimulus was too small, but they would come down in favor of it.


The Administration would like this idea. It would give them two years of breathing room.


The Fed would love this plan. This is what Bernanke has been advocating. The IMF and the rest of the G-20 would hail it.


The Republicans would hate it, but what can they do but complain? After all, the Reds did get clobbered in the election. Republicans want to keep the tax rate on those making more than $250k and they definitely want to avoid cutbacks in military spending. If Republicans play hardball, they will lose big. They know that they are cornered. To save face, and to have a say in the outcome, they might go along, provided they got the “big” prize. A chance to change the tax code.


The grand compromise that could make this happen is a legislative commitment to rewrite the tax code. There would have to be a “promise” to achieve the necessary tax-code changes within twelve months. If there were no agreement on the changes in tax laws by 12/31/13, then the country would revert to falling off the cliff.


I think there is going to be a can-kick. I think it will include all the existing tax issues (Bush cuts and AMT). The sequestered cut backs in spending will be pushed out for a year. But, importantly, the 2% payroll tax break will not be extended.  As part of the deal, there will be a promise to write the tax code.


We’ll see what Obama has to say in a few hours. Obama is no dope. He knows that the market cap of all US stocks is down by $600Bn the last few days. He knows that the market wants a can-kick. He knows that a tax re-write is necessary. He knows that the economy needs a boost. He knows that there is next to nobody left who gives a damn about the debt picture. He knows that Bernanke will buy up all the extra paper that comes with this plan. So I think the “grand can-kick” is in the future.



  1. chance you take says:

    Stop the motor of the world. They voted for it, now let them have it.

    No soup today, but there may be another bread distribution on Tuesday

    • But What Do I Know? says:

      Keep quoting your adolescent literature as if it had a bearing on the real world and no one is going to take you seriously.

      • all the right words, touched your arm at the right times, got you haawlfy home (the bar near his place, at closing) and then to his place. He got you to leave (ostensibly after sex wrestling ? C’mon, Kate, just tell us you did him), and got you to go away for good after insisting you see his FB page.This is step by step from one of those How to Get Women websites, right? And the most important step, for those kind of guys, is getting you to leave, after the boinking.Maybe its penance for being so mean to those other loser guys .Cheers!

      • Juan Gomez October 4, 2011 From now on, I’m gonna try and sum up Kate’s date experience in 5 words or less so you won’t have to read tuhrogh all that stuff, kind of a condensed Cliff notes. This one is easy:Trent Likes to kill animals, sunk by Facebook. Next!

    • hassan Posted on You can name your blog on your own name like miror, one thing more, you should name it aiccrdong to your interest.

    • My Data Manager means that you can take control of your mboile phone data. Keep an eye on app data usage for your home together with roaming options. Establish use alerts to handle your invoice. Keep track of past use | usage | utilization to make sure you are buying the ideal coverage plus optimize how you make use of the data. Watch per app data utilization to know what apps are consuming the most data, and what programs are usually almost free. Economize with your data plans more effectively. Please be aware that My Data Manager works with Android units having 2.2+ Operating system

  2. Of course there will be a can-kick. What other option is there? And you are right about nobody caring about the debt, not because they choose not to care, but because the numbers are beyond comprehension. I mean, how do you comprehend, in any meaningful way, analogies such as: a $1T is 32,000 years worth of seconds,or, spending $1M per day from the time of Jesus until today is still less than one trillion dollar. Our common sense has been replaced by politicians and lawyers, and our sensibilities are numb. We will continue our all-hail-the-king marching until we crash to the bare essentials, and we then start to build a new foundation; maybe in our lifetime, maybe not.

  3. Democrats have a problem in that 20 senators are up for election in 2014 while the Republicans have only 13 and those are very safe RED states. Obama understands the math if he is going to get anything he wants then its now or never. If the Bush upper tax cuts are extended it will be a mark against the Democrats during the next cycle since he has been saying they will not be extended since his first term. Elections do have consequences and the Democrats have a base that does expect to extract higher taxes from the 1%.

  4. But What Do I Know? says:

    Well, hell, if we’re not going to worry about the deficit, why not extend the payroll tax cut along with all the other goodies? Oh, right, no one in Congress gives a sh*t about working people.

  5. Jim,MtnViewCA,USA says:

    “Republicans want to keep the tax rate on those making more than $250k”
    Yahoo says 8 of the 10 richest counties voted for Obama. Lots of rich people on Wall Street and Hollywood are big supporters of blue causes. Maybe Repubs won’t want to raise rates on the 250K crowd, but they could easily support raising taxes on $1M crowd. And, for purely political reasons….they should.

  6. There will be can-kicking and there better had be. America is the greatest Ponzi-scheme ever devised. There is option but can-kicking. Once the can stops rolling, the whole thing goes down like the Hindenburg.

  7. Crocodile Chuck says:

    WTF does the stock market being down $600B have to do with anything?

    • genome468 on January 14, 2011 i checked out your site. not bad. its done prttey much like craigslist so i enjoyed the familiarity. A question tho. how long has the site been up? This can grow to be a big thing just like craigslist.. good luck to ya

    • I understand the jgndemeut after looking at his Facebook page; I’m a person who believes that the company one keeps can be a major tell-tale sign of their own personality. Hunting pictures, now that’s definitely an individual preference. I’m an outdoors type myself, including hunting and fishing, so I would have been less jgndemeutal of bloody carcasses.

  8. >>>WTF does the stock market being down $600B have to do with anything?<<<

    It's the only the rubes can understand to ascertain 'How we're doing'. It's their 401K's.

    • e.l Posted on For one thing unless they’re psilbuhed you mean writers’.Only you can decide when, as it needs to fit round you and your members’ schedules.

    • An impressive share, I just given this onto a colalegue who was doing a little analysis on this. And he in fact bought me breakfast because I found it for him.. smile. So let me reword that: Thnx for the treat! But yeah Thnkx for spending the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love reading more on this topic. If possible, as you become expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more details? It is highly helpful for me. Big thumb up for this blog post!.

  9. It’s the only =thing=. Sorry for typo.

  10. “He knows that Bernanke will buy up all the extra paper that comes with this plan. So I think the “grand can-kick” is in the future.”

    Bruce, technically isn’t Bernanke going to be busy buying up MBS.

  11. Howdy! Would you mind if I share your blog
    with my facebook group? There’s a lot of folks that I think would really enjoy your content. Please let me know. Thanks

  12. Works well! It is not obvious, thuogh. Will new users know to click on the yellow bubble or time stamp?Within the thread itself, perhaps you can put the same yellow bubble next to the title of the thread to keep things consistent? Maybe a yellow bubble with a down arrow?

  13. Merely want to say your write-up is as amazing. The crality inside your post is basically nice and i can assume you’re an professional on this subject. Nicely with your permission allow me to grab your feed to maintain as much as date with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please maintain up the gratifying work.